Question from Anonymous: “Ryan Adams or The Beatles?”
How you just gonna ask me that?
Well, you probably already know that I’m not just going to pick one. If this were a Facebook relationship status, it would be “it’s complicated.”
As you also probably already know, this is an apples-and-oranges question for me. Not that Ryan wasn’t possibly influenced a little, at least indirectly, by the Beatles (I maintain that he channels John Lennon in “Beautiful Sorta“)—everyone was, pretty much—but they’re not exactly musical colleagues.
Thus, it would be beyond absurd to discuss the musical merit of each and somehow come up with a “winner.” I guess the intent of the question is closer to which is my preference, or which means more to me.
I don’t know. Weirdly, I don’t listen to either on a regular basis. Is that shocking? Let me explain, if I can. Yes, I have both of their catalogues pretty much memorized. Yes, I list each of them at the top of the list of…just about every earthly thing that I love the most.
There’s just this point that a small number of artists reach in my consciousness that I will awkwardly label for the purposes of this post as The Point of Meaning Too Much. I’ve cried myriad times over myriad songs by both artists. I have at least one memory attached to each song of each, as well. Each has given me chills, blown my mind, freaked me out, altered my thinking, widened my eyes, and caused me to shake my head on hundreds, if not thousands, of occasions.
I just can’t handle that kind of thing too often. I save my iPod spins of each of them for when I get a specific album jones—for instance, sometimes you just need the White Album—or even a specific song jones. I mean, how would I have ugly-cried my way through a handful of heartaches without “Now That You’re Gone“?
I’ve years’ worth of evidences of my obsessions with both the Beatles and Ryan Adams. The former changed everything for me in my adolescence. The latter changed everything for me in my early 20s. I’m not willing to part with either.
***
I’m closing in on the questions that have been sitting in my Formspring inbox for weeks! Ask me more.




